Autograph collectors all encounter it at one time or another:
the perfectly illegible autograph. The impossible convulsive scrawl of Giacomo
Puccini, or the idiosyncratic tremor of the Duke of Wellington—interpreting autographs like these is almost always frustrating, but they are especially so in more
informal letters. One wonders how the recipients of such letters could
understand them at all! Surprisingly, the recipients could often read even the
hastiest lines with little trouble, because they were familiar with the
orthographic style of the writer and the conventions among writers in those
places and times.
Lot 65: Sigmund Freud, Autograph Note Signed, a bill for one of his last
patients, Vienna, 31 January 1934. Estimate $3,000 to $4,000.
In Vienna during the 19th century, the script
that was taught in schools was quite different from that in the
non-German speaking parts of the world, and different as well from the German
script of the present-day. This style of script is known as Kurrentschrift, and it was used in the
same way that (some of us) use cursive today.
Sigmund Freud, for instance, wrote letters, scribbled analyst’s notes and
signed his name, in Kurrentschrift.
An example of his characteristic signature can be seen in lots 65 and 66 of
Swann’s 22 October autographs auction. Although Freud is known to have signed his
name in other ways, he often signed “freud.” The capital and lowercase “F” of Kurrentschrift are very similar in form,
but not identical. Freud wrote these two letterforms identically, not only in
his name, but universally. Despite this slight stylistic liberty, recipients of
Freud’s letters would undoubtedly have recognized that “first National Bank” and “freud”
were intended to be understood as capitalized.
Lot 66: Sigmund Freud, Typed Letter Signed "freud," Vienna, 24 March 1926. Estimate $2,000 to $3,000.
The painter Egon Schiele, living at roughly the same time
and place as Freud, also wrote in Kurrentschrift.
No amount of familiarity with Schiele’s peculiarities would have rendered
understandable the printer’s error in the catalogue for his 1916 Kunstschau exhibition. In that
catalogue, illustrations of two of his works were either ascribed to a different
painter, or titled inaccurately. In some copies of this catalogue, including
the one on offer in lot 384 of Swann’s October auction, Schiele marked through
the erroneous print and wrote the correct information below.
Lot 384: Katalog der Wiener Kunstschau signed and inscribed by Egon Schiele,
1916. Estimate $6,000 to $9,000.
While Freud intended his name to be capitalized and was
somewhat indifferent as to how it was written, e.e. cummings was famously
insistent that his name be printed entirely in lowercase letters. As he
explained in the letter contained in lot 318 of Swann’s October auction,
cummings conceived of the capitalization of words referring to himself the same
way that European languages used capitalization of first-person pronouns: written
in lowercase, unless capitals were needed to convey emphasis. Paradoxically,
cummings signed the letter in lot 318 with capital letters—perhaps for
Lot 318:e.e. cummings, Typed Note Signed "E.E. Cg's," on the choice to
utilize lowercase letters for his name, New York, 21 February 1957.
Estimate $800 to $1,200.
It is hardly surprising that e.e. cummings was sensitive about
the spelling of his name. One’s name often suggests certain associations, and
desiring control over them is natural. Edvard Grieg, a composer who was proud
to be Norwegian, was not pleased by the English association conveyed when his
name was sloppily spelled “Edward.” In an 1893 letter, offered in lot 254 of
Swann’s October auction, this impatience is made explicit: “With great
pleasure, use my name, but—on one condition: without the ‘W’! My name is ‘Edvard.’
Excuse me but this is my sore spot.”
Lot 254: Edvard Grieg, Autograph Letter Signed, correcting a common
misspelling of his name, Bergen, 22 September. Estimate $1,000 to
cummings sought to subvert some orthographic conventions
concerning his name to show his personal preference for other conventions.
President Harry S. Truman, by contrast, did not mind leaving it up to others
when it came to his own name. As Truman points out in the letter being offered
in lot 217 of Swann’s October auction, Truman is satisfied to have the “S” in
his middle name followed by a period—or without one. Editors encountering his
name must make a choice about this, because his given middle name is the letter
“S.” As he explains in the letter, he was given this name to honor his
grandfathers, Andrew Shippe Truman and Solomon Young: “In order to be strictly
impartial in naming me for one or the other, I was given the letter ‘S’ as a
Lot 217: Harry S. Truman, Typed Letter Signed, explaining his middle name,
Independence, 26 July, 1967. Estimate $500 to $750.
Perhaps the most remarkable orthographic autograph in
Swann’s October auction is Noah Webster’s letter (lot 362) to a group of
conservative editors, in which he touches upon his justification for the
spelling reforms introduced in his American
Dictionary, 1828. He states that his reforms are not innovations, rather
corrections: “The ignorance or negligence which introduced wrong spelling,
&, in some cases, made words which are nonsense, & then permitted these
words to occupy a place in our best books, even in the Bible, for centuries;
appeared to me an abuse of the language not to be tolerated.” Webster signed
his letter “N Webster,” and though he just as often signed his full name, he
did not tolerate alternative spellings of his name.
Lot 362: Noah Webster, Autograph Letter Signed "N Webster," directing unnamed
editors to sources justifying his spelling reforms.
William Shakespeare, who was writing long after the Bible
was written and long before Webster was born, signed his last name “Shakspere,” or “Shaksper,” or in other ways;
but his tolerance for spelling variation was not uncommon, and it extended to
not only personal names, but to the written language generally. Despite the
lack of standardized spelling, probably all who knew him would understand just
who was meant when encountering any of the various instances of Shakespeare’s
name, and it would seem surprising if the number of any sort of
misunderstanding among writers was greater in his day than today. Nevertheless,
it is likely that writers will never cease to labour to give each thing its true
name. Or rather I should say labor.
More information on these items and additional autographs can be found in our catalogue.
Labels: autographs, e.e. cummings, Edvard Grieg, Egon Schiele, Harry Truman, Noah Webster, Sigmund Freud